
Introduction to There, We Said
By Patricia Maloney, Melissa MillerCriticism fails if it doesn’t understand that it plays a supporting role to discussions in real time and space.
More »There, we said, and in this place. How are we to think of there? And this taking place or this having a place...Jacques Derrida, Archive Fever
Art Practical was launched five years ago, on October 29, 2009. The first issue included two features, six reviews, and a shotgun review. We have gone on to publish an additional 102 issues, including this one. In the process, we have also continually worked to demonstrate the powerful results that thoughtful, rigorous criticism can produce. So, on this notable anniversary, we focus our attention on our purpose and core activity: criticism itself.
This issue also serves as an introduction to the expanded partnership that Art Practical is embarking on with California College of the Arts, in which the magazine serves as a tool for project-based learning and professional development. The students in the CCA Art Practical Collaborative who have curated this issue participate in an elective seminar that examines the various stances by which art publications define critical discourse for their audiences; they also contribute to the publication throughout the semester.
What follows is their selection of individual texts that have characterized our objectives to experiment; to articulate artists’ voices; to be self-reflective, evaluative, and adaptive; to best represent the practices of the Bay Area cultural communities; and to believe in the informed personal description of the encounter with an artwork.
Criticism is ultimately an exercise in prospecting, in staking claims. It delineates proximity and distance to individuals, ideas, and spaces. Art Practical defies the notion that we are losing our claims on this city, because artists and writers have been writing their story here every week for the past five years, rendering this place in their image. The articles included here are testaments of why we persist and for whom. Enjoy.—Patricia Maloney with Melissa Miller
Pipilotti Rist. Pepperminta, 2009; film still. Courtesy of the Artist.
Criticism fails if it doesn’t understand that it plays a supporting role to discussions in real time and space.
More »Liking or not is often not the point, or if so, it is an ulterior point. The main point is to give people something to read
More »How come there is more advertising space than content in most art magazines? Why is it often so hard to tell the difference?
More »In an aesthetic experience, these faculties are in “free play”: the imagination is not in service of cognition, and the mind is not overwhelmed by perception.
More »If subject-object oppositions indicate the problematics of social practice, how do we rethink and reorganize this concept?
More »As I continued to work, it became clearer to me that I was creating a world that would attempt to redefine my reality.
More »As the region’s traditional art world has struggled, Burning Man and its maker ecosystem has slowly risen to become the vox populi of the Bay Area arts.
More »What kinds of strategies might artists employ to create a sense of agency when it comes to artistic production? What are the key questions artists should ask themselves in seeking to define standards for valuing their labor?
More »I had only been in Marfa for one week, and I had no expectations for the art scene other than for it to be a unique and eclectic social milieu.
More »Do scholars and critics deliberately avoid writing about what makes funny art funny, and if so, why? Is it just difficult for critics and scholars to take humor seriously?
More »There’s a certain critical laziness where you don’t have to engage with the object, you can just respond verbally to other verbal notions, so you don't have to engage with the instability of perception.
More »If anything, the imagined reader has been a judge sitting on my shoulders whose image I have to shut out if I’m going to get any words down on the page.
More »Constantly learning, constantly reading—I would stay a student, basically, which is what I consider what I am, and I love that.
More »One of the things that I love about performance is that if you weren’t there, then you weren’t there. It does disappear, and we disappear
More »Prelinger describes his films as being in “a perpetual state of incompletion,” and he urges his audience to construct their own narratives
More »Humanness is a function of participation in social and economic systems rather than a realm of lived experience.
More »Society should both demand from and reward the arts community for more engagement, by more people, with more, better art.
More »As different as Delvoye and Pauline may appear, they seem to draw the same conclusions regarding the art world and its economic demands.
More »With essays and interviews exploring the full spectrum of speech acts—from talking to publishing, both online and offline—this issue of Art Practical takes up the question of free speech in the art world.
The contributions to this issue consider production and process, reveal cultural breadth, conceptual range, and possibilities of making, using, and thinking through textiles.
The twenty-one shotgun reviews by new and returning contributors collected here offer thoughtful impressions of fall and late summer exhibitions in the Bay Area, launching us into another exciting year of critical and engaging dialogue.